When I say things like some of my students have never been
to an airport before, I’m not kidding. At first, one would say that it is not
so shocking. After all, they are only thirteen years old. But it doesn’t end
there. I was shocked to learn that some of my students have never been to
Frankfurt! Wölfersheim is 45 minutes from Frankfurt by train. I think any place
you go in Hessen is no more than 45 minutes away from Frankfurt.
Last Tuesday, I went on a field trip with my 8th
grade Hauptschule class to the Frankfurt airport. Knock out two birds with one
stone I guess? To be honest, I was dreading it. I really like my students, but
I know how disruptive they can be in the classroom. Being responsible for 20
teenagers out in the wild? No thank you!
I’m pleased to say my students proved me wrong. They were
extremely well behaved. They loved the 90-minute bus tour we took, driving
around the runways and identifying planes from all over the world. They pointed
out every airplane taking off or landing and snapped tons of pictures.
Me on the other hand, I was struggling to understand the
German. I was exhausted from a few nights of bad sleep. On top of that, the bus
was so warm and cozy…Bad combination! Let’s just say it took everything in me
to stay awake.
I can’t emphasize enough how great they acted. We even let
them have a free hour for lunch to roam around the airport. And everyone showed
up in time to catch our train home. If only they were like this in the
classroom.
Here is why I am so pleasantly surprised. Hauptschule
students are those who perform at a lower academic level. You find learning
disabilities, autism, and foreigners in these classes. This is not special ed
though--not by any means. Hauptschule students are placed together in a track
that will prepare them for service and trade jobs after they finish the 9th
or 10th class. In some ways, this is great. These students have a
guided path that will give them valuable training and job stability.
But now I must digress…
I am not convinced that this system works or that this is
the right thing to do. I see my Hauptschule students in comparison to the
Realschule and Gymnasium students.
They are being told by their peers, their teachers, even their parents, and
the rest of German society that they cannot do better for themselves.
Many would argue that this system is Germany’s own way of
leaving no child behind. It ensures that everyone is able to succeed in life,
no matter his or her level of intelligence. But the sad reality is that nobody
wants to be placed in Hauptschule, it’s for “losers”. They will wear scarlet Hs
for the rest of their lives.
To me, this is so un-American. The American Dream is to pull
yourself up by your bootstraps; that anyone who works hard enough can succeed;
that nobody can hold you back. Okay, sure, if a student was wrongly placed into
Hauptschule, they could switch tracks (this is a big argument in favor of this
system). But it rarely happens, and it is not easy to do.
And think about it; if everyone around you is telling you
that you are not smart, that you are not worthy of more in life, wouldn’t you
believe them? Why wouldn’t a ten year old believe that about him/herself?
What’s more, a majority of the parents could care less. It
is a vicious cycle because they were probably Hauptschule students themselves.
They work hard and long hours and see the value in practical training, not convoluted
university prep. If a student is having discipline issues, many will say it is the
teacher’s job to fix it.
Maybe me as the American spectator is the problem. What if
these kids really can’t achieve more in life, have no desire to pull themselves
up from the bottom of society? Perhaps they would end up in the same place, no
matter how the school system was structured. This naturally seems to happen in
the United States anyway.
There are so many varying opinions about this system and you
can probably see why. I know I keep coming back to this subject. I feel very
compelled to work with my Hauptschule students and to understand them better.
Working with this class is no picnic, but I enjoy the challenge and truly love these guys!



